The Power of Story, by Carole Howard

The joy of story-telling is more-or-less always on my mind because my granddaughter and I frequently make up stories. They usually involve playgrounds and dinosaurs and they’re always a hoot.

I recently saw a more serious kind of story, though (lucky me!): Pierro della Francesca’s “The Legend of the True Cross” in Arezzo, Italy. I was awe-struck by the 15th century frescoes’ power to tell a story to a population who, largely, couldn’t read or write. The story told is how the wood from the Garden of Eden became the cross on which Christ was crucified.

From an art history point of view, I learned, the frescoes are remarkable for their geometrical perspective and the elegance of the Biblical figures presented. From a religious point of view, the series is important because of the way it integrates various parts of the narrative.

Queen of Sheba Meeting with Solomon, from The Legend of the True Cross Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons

Queen of Sheba Meeting with Solomon, from The Legend of the True Cross
Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons


For me, even with my limited knowledge of art history or the Bible, it was a breathtaking moment.

There I was, in the Basilica of San Francesco, surrounded by 10 beautiful and enormous paintings with exquisite detail and glorious colors telling an oft-told story in a new way. “Wow” doesn’t do it justice, but it does capture my reaction.





And I got to thinking about the power and uses of story-telling – and not just the ones with playgrounds and dinosaurs.

Some stories deliver a message, like the one my mother told (and re-told) of my grandmother, in Poland at the end of the nineteenth century, coming to America. Her parents were against the idea, but she persisted. (Parents of 16-year olds can relate to this.) The rabbi advised them that she only wanted to leave because they didn’t want her to. If they gave her permission, even provided the money, she’d never leave. (Reverse psychology, way back when!) You know what happened next. The rabbi was wrong.

Tragically, her father followed her to America to bring her home and, while here, had a fatal heart attack. My mother never added, “The moral of the story is that if you go against your parents, dreadful things can happen.” She didn’t have to; the story did the work.

Others package up a universal truth (Emperor’s New Clothes, Boy Who Cried Wolf), introduce us to endless variations of characters and situations, transport us, sell a political candidate (don’t get me started!), or teach us about history. Often, the narrative becomes the truth.

(I hate to admit it, but my husband has been saying this for years. Every time he tells a story and I point out that it’s not exactly the way it happened, he insists it doesn’t matter.)

For example, what did George Washington say after he chopped down the cherry tree? Not so fast. He didn’t say “I cannot tell a lie.” In fact, he didn’t even chop down that tree. It’s a great story to demonstrate his integrity and courage, but it didn’t actually happen.

And many of my religious friends tell me they don’t think biblical stories need to be taken literally, as history. Maybe the Red Sea didn’t actually part, they say. It doesn’t matter. The story resonates. The story tells a truth, they say, more important than the historical truth.

Is that why we write? To tell a story that conveys a truth, whether literal or not? Even if it’s “only” our own personal truth?   And is that why we read, to hear others’ truths? Or is it more about entertainment?

And what stories have particular resonance for you, whether they’re literally true or not? For me, there’s the story of the prodigal son (aka my brother), which showed me a helpful way to interpret a family dynamic. And then there’s the forever-haunting story told in Sophie’s Choice. And, of course, there’s the story of my magnolia, which is absolutely, positively 100% true!

And many more. How about you?

* * *

Carole Howard is the author of Deadly Adagio, published by Second Wind Publishing.



Filed under writing

11 responses to “The Power of Story, by Carole Howard

  1. Nice little essay; a few years ago, corporate America dialed into the power of stories. I was at IBM at the time. Oh – the tales I could tell (and have, actually), but not yet put in my latest collection of Senior Scribbles. Your piece was very evocative of the topic.

  2. Carole, I love your magnolia story so much! Two other top favorites are the fairy tale “Thumbelina” and the great “Beloved.”

  3. Thanks, Chuck. (Is it Chuck who wrote the comment? The name on the comment is both of you but the picture is you……) Having been a corporate consultant about a hundred years ago, I’d love to hear some of your IBM stories. We could trade them, like baseball cards. And where do I find your Senior Scribbles? Are they “out there”?

  4. Nicole, thanks so much! And I love that you put the magnolia story in the same sentence (well, in a succeeding sentence) as “Thumbelina” and “Beloved.” I haven’t read Thumbelina for ages, but I still remember Beloved and I, too, find that story amazing.

  5. Carole, I enjoyed this post so much. Stories do so much: entertain, inspire, encourage, touch the heart and make us ponder. Today, you’ve made me ponder. Thanks!

  6. And thanks to you, too Coco! Pondering is great.

  7. Hi Carole – Yep, I (Chuck) am responsible for the comment. Agree – we should investigate sharing some corporate fables! My two books of Senior Scribbles are avail on Amazon. A 3rd is in the works.

  8. Great, Chuck. Am heading right on over to Amazon.

  9. This is so beautifully written, Carole! I love the power of a story. I must say (and I am as shocked by this as you are!) that I agree with Geoffrey on this one: it isn’t the factual truth of the story that matters, it’s that the story has the power to convey how it really FELT to live through that story. I always think of James Frey being fried by Oprah over the “untruths” in his “memoir,” “A Million Little Pieces.” In the interview/slaughter with Oprah, he said something to the effect of “maybe that isn’t how it really happened, but that’s how it felt.” I’ve never forgotten that, it made SO much sense to me, and has made me feel so much better about the creative license I take in telling my own stories 🙂 I didn’t know your magnolia story, but it gave me chills reading it! Love!

  10. Thank you so much, Sarah, for your enthusiasm and your thoughtfulness. I’m going to write you a personal email with details!

  11. Pingback: In Competence | carolejhoward

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.