Who’s Your Daddy? by J J Dare

A few weeks ago, a friend of mine discovered that the man she’d called “Daddy” from her first memory was not, in fact, her biological father. He died at the beginning of this year and her mother had passed away in 1996, so she couldn’t ask why her entire life had been lived under such a huge deception.

She found two birth certificates in her name in boxes she’d been too grief-stricken to go through until now. The dates were within seventeen months of each other. Her mother’s name was on the older certificate, but “Unknown” was listed, matter-of-factly, under “Father’s Name.” On the newer certificate, her Daddy’s name was listed.

The interesting part of the story is she is a middle child. She has two older siblings and a younger one. The older siblings were no help beyond the memory of staying at their maternal grandmother’s home for a little while (they were toddlers, so had no true sense of time passing) when their mother and father moved a few states away to follow their father’s job in the oil field. Her older brothers remembered when they reunited with their parents, she was a baby.

There is no one left alive to explain. Her parents’ immediate families are long gone. The current relatives are too many generations removed to know the real story of her conception, birth and life.

The only clue is an old Ohio State Fair schedule from 1957. Tennessee Ernie Ford, Ricky Nelson, Matt Dillon and Rin Tin Tin were the draws. We ruled them all out as possible blood fathers.

My friend was born in March of 1958. Her parents moved from south central Florida to Louisiana in 1957, the time her older brothers stayed with their grandparents. Ohio was pointedly out of the way.

She found her daddy’s old pay stubs from that time, so we know he was in Louisiana and working in the Gulf on a rig. Her mother was a housewife and had never worked a day in her life. Well, that we knew of. There was a gap in the family’s history and no pictures or letters from that time have been found except for the Ohio State Fair schedule, the oil rig payroll records and those interesting birth certificates.

Instead of obsessing over why, who, when and where, my friend let go of the questions that could never be answered and said, “Well, this explains a lot.”

Her father always treated her differently than her siblings and, although she was the one who took care of him as he aged, he was always distant and somewhat cold toward my friend. I saw his attitude toward my friend on a few occasions, so I agreed with her wrap-it-up statement.

No Mystery: I have features from Mom and Dad. I’m definitely their spawn.

Eventually, answers to unknowns make themselves known. Or they don’t matter. In my friend’s case, she now understands her father’s lack of love toward her. She was a constant reminder to him of something he’d rather forget. Although she was blameless, the act of her birth caused him pain or shame or something she’d never know. In the end, it didn’t matter because the important question of her life had been answered: she knew why she felt no love from the only father she’d ever known.

Sometimes it takes a lifetime to answer a question that haunts you. Sometimes the question is never answered. You will go to your grave without an answer. On television the other day, a man was anxious to find his own answer before he died. His friend astutely said, “Even if you don’t find out, you’ll be dead and it won’t matter.” How true.

Mystery: if you drop your wallet or cellphone in THIS toilet, is it really worth retrieving at the bottom of the ravine?

In my case, I found out, after over two decades, why someone I had worked with absolutely loathed me. Not just hated me; loathed me with a black heart. I remember being apathetic toward her way back in the day, but I’d done nothing to deserve her hate. Or so I thought.

At the time, I thought it was some action of mine that incurred her fury. I’m rather passive-aggressive, so I just brushed her off and forgot about her. I tossed her out of my mind and life. I didn’t think about her at all until recently when I found out why she abhorred me.

It wasn’t the me of me she hated. It was my influence over a third party that she detested. Her attitude was junior-high and immature for her twenty-something years (which, I heard, she never matured out of – her emotional development stopped at age fourteen). Since we worked together, her sudden change from friendly coworker to arch-enemy puzzled me, but since she had the intelligence of a hat rack, I felt no threat from her.

When I found out the reason, it explained a lot. For awhile, I was furious. Just like my fatherless friend, I was able to put pieces of a puzzle together. The funny thing was, the more pieces I put together, the bigger the finished puzzle became. I came away knowing a lot more about this former coworker/friend/enemy than I knew what to do with.

So, I wrote a book.

I started with parts of my history, her history and our shared third-party person’s history. It’s not a love triangle story, if that’s what you think. It’s more of a love-hate, hate-hate, hate-love, love-love octagon. While writing the story, it occurred to me that I had been a focus in her life for much, much longer than she had been a thought in mine. I influenced without knowing it.

Curiously, I still influence although I have no contact with her. I hear things through the grapevine. One of the things I heard is titillating. Her youngest children look nothing like their older sibling or father. Nothing. They do, however, resemble a mutual friend.  Small-town fodder for another story.

Mystery Solved: They don’t get along because the cat is just plain mean and the dog is way too nice.

Stories can take great liberties but as writers we must always provide a plausible explanation. Plausible, but not easy. Readers will see easy answers as lazy writing. The best is the answer that makes the reader say, “Aha.”

Life, books, secrets, answers. Everything has an explanation but sometimes only one person knows the answer and that one person may take their answers with them. There are no mysteries in life, only mysteries within our own lives.

J J Dare is the author of two published books, several short stories and triple digit works-in-progress.

Current enthusiasm is sharpening intangible knives and co-authoring at Rubicon Ranch


Filed under books, writing

7 responses to “Who’s Your Daddy? by J J Dare

  1. Answers don’t always make themselves known, J J; nor do they not matter, unless we remain ignorant of the question.

    Funny how it seems the more answers to questions we obtain, the more questions arise. I recently started a bible study and we’re studying John. Sure, I’m learning a lot; but I also find myself with more questions. Questions that will likely never be answered.

    A fine blog post, J J.

  2. dellanioakes

    JJ, great post! Makes me highly curious what you did that so angered your ex co-worker. Funny how some people never let go of something we consider so forgettable.

    • Nancy Niles

      Interesting post. I too have a family member who has seemed to hate me since my first memories – age 4. Just recently I’ve begun again asking myself why and wishing for answers.
      Could be nothing more than I got a popsicle one day and he didn’t.
      I had a friend who grew up thinking his grandmother was the meanest person on earth. When someone pressed him into telling them HOW she was mean he remembered that when he was 6 years old she wouldn’t let him have dinner unless he washed his hands.
      Man, that’s mean!
      Funny how as adults we still carry decisions we made with a child’s mind.

  3. Fascinating how the untold secrets can hold at least as much power as those things we beat ourselves up for.

  4. Deborah Landry

    Love that story i want more!

  5. What an ordeal for your friend, and unless her biological father (or one of his other children) tracks her down, the truth will likely remain hidden. It’s possible the father didn’t know her mother was pregnant. Or the other common scenario, he was married, said he would leave his wife, but when push came to shove, didn’t.

    When you mentioned that your former co-worker had not emotionaly matured past 14, it hit me that it’s common in people who have been abused, that they are emotionally locked at the age the abuse began. Her behavior certainly suggests an abnormality. We have all kinds of experiences in this life.

    Great post!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.